Welcome to Jeremiah's Tavern
Nestled in Fairport, NY, Jeremiah's Tavern offers a delightful dining experience that marries comfort food with warm hospitality. Renowned for its extensive menu, patrons rave about the iconic Bruschetta Pizza and the succulent Bee Sting Fried Chicken. The vibrant atmosphere invites both outdoor dining and gathering with friends, making it ideal for any occasion. Customer favorites include the flavorful soups—particularly the famous French onion soup—and generous salads. The attentive staff, highlighted by service that feels personal and welcoming, truly enhances the experience. Whether you're craving pizza, burgers, or classic salads, Jeremiah's Tavern guarantees quality and satisfaction in every bite.
-
2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, Fairport, NY 14450, United States2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, Fairport, NY 14450, United States Hotline: +1 585-377-2233
Welcome to Jeremiah's Tavern, a delightful dining gem nestled in Fairport, New York. With its cozy atmosphere and a diverse menu that brims with flavor, Jeremiah's Tavern is the ideal spot for anyone looking to indulge in mouth-watering sandwiches, wraps, and burgers. Conveniently located at 2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, this eatery has quickly earned a reputation for delivering quality food paired with exceptional service.
The heart of Jeremiah's Tavern lies in its impressive menu, featuring an array of tantalizing options. For those craving something hearty, the French Dip showcases house-roasted beef and Swiss cheese nestled in a toasted artisan baguette, served with a savory au jus for dipping. The Turkey Bacon Avocado Wrap is a refreshing choice, skillfully combining turkey, bacon, and ripe avocado. And let’s not forget the signature Build A Better Burger, where fresh ground sirloin is nestled into a brioche bun, allowing you to customize with a variety of toppings to meet your cravings.
Customer experiences highlight the warm and welcoming ambiance of Jeremiah's Tavern. Kelley Smith noted the kind staff who generously recommended their favorites, while Sarah shared her appreciation for the generous portions of their expertly crafted salads. Whether you’re enjoying the crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap or the luscious Buffalo Chicken Wrap, you can expect nothing short of flavorful satisfaction. Lynne Murray raved about their bruschetta pizza, highlighting the good service and enjoyable meals enjoyed with friends.
Don’t miss the famous French Onion Soup, hailed by Kris Mancini as the best in the Rochester area; its rich seasoning and fresh ingredients are unforgettable. For special occasions, diners like Ellen Bray have found a touch of personal warmth from the attentive staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable experience. It’s this dedication to service, along with the quality of food, that keeps patrons returning time after time.
Overall, Jeremiah's Tavern is more than just a restaurant; it's a greater experience where friends gather, families dine, and the food is always a reason to celebrate. If you’re ever in the area, be sure to stop by and enjoy a meal that will leave your taste buds dancing. Your next favorite food adventure awaits!
Delicious! Waitress was super kind and recommended favorites on the menu. My guests got the Bee-hive salad (said it was SUPERRR hot but delicious) and nachos. I got the schnitzel sandwich, bread was so tender, sauce was delicious, macaroni salad was so good! Hey quality food. There was a wait - surprisingly packed for a Monday! We did outdoor dining which was a nice option. Masks were few and far between to be seen here. Would definitely go back.
Great place to eat in Penfield. Fast service and great food. Generous portions on top of the salads. Highly recommend. I enjoyed the Classic Caesar Chicken Salad but this time I went with the classic Caesar shrimp salad.
Met up with 5 friends. We sat at a very large booth. Service was great, the food was very good. I had the bruschetta pizza and enjoyed it very much. This was my second time eating here. I would highly recommend this place.
BY FAR! Theeee BEST French onion soup in the Rochester area. I have multiple restaurants and none even closely compare. Fresh and so well seasoned. Amazing service and quality of food! I have never had a bad meal at this Penfield location. Next time you are in GET THE ONION SOUP
Jennifer our waitress was absolutely amazing! She made us feel so comfortable and right at home. She made suggestions for my meal and sang me Happy Birthday! Will ask for her whenever I come to Jeremiahs.
There was 8 of us here without a reservation on 2/8 at about 12:30 in the afternoon and Jasmine took care of us. From the start she was incredibly helpful with everything from getting the game we were looking for along with getting us situated upon arrival without hesitation. Consistently checked on us throughout and everyone was happy. Can't say enough as start to finish was great and look forward to coming back!
We are long-time Jeremiah's lovers (PLEASE BRING BACK THE PORK SCHNITZEL SANDWICH!). We bring family from out of town, have been there with big groups for work dinners, and enjoy going on Monday's for a free kiddo dinner. The food is always great, and the service is even better. A server who we've been lucky enough to have over several visits is Jennifer. She is so patient and kind, and at the same time keeps things moving. I remember being with a large group over a year ago, and there were two big groups in the side room in Penfield, and it felt like we were her only table. Really appreciate great team members like Jennifer who keep us coming back to Jeremiah's :)
Had a great dinner tonight. Casual, friendly place with good food. Our server, Jennifer, made the experience delightful. She was friendly, prompt, and just very welcoming!